As a fairly new teacher, only teaching for 5 years, I have not had too many opportunities to evaluate educational technology. In my first classroom the word “technology” was non-existent. I had three computers…really old computers…that only worked when they felt like it. They were really old and really slow, which pretty much made them useless. Every time I tried to put a student on the computer it would stop working. So those computers just collected dust in the back of my classroom. When I moved to a new school, however, I felt like I had won the lottery! I had four computers (that actually worked!), a projector, a document camera, and audio enhancement equipment.
I was in heaven! After acclimating myself to my new technologies, I quickly realized that since I now had all of this amazing equipment, I was expected to use it as much as possible. The projector was amazing, the document camera was incredible, the audio enhancement equipment saved me from raising my voice so often, but the computers were not being used to the best of their ability. At my school there is an educational software program called Successmaker that our students are expected to use every day. While I think that this program has its perks and does a decent job of measuring my student’s reading and math levels, I just wish that we had the freedom to use some other great educational software to support our students’ learning. Since I teach kindergarten the only educational software we use is Successmaker, but I know the older grades have other required software they need to use as well. My students get really bored with the Successmaker program because it keeps repeating the same activities over and over until they are mastered. I feel like sometimes I am forcing my students to do it because that is what they are required to do.
If I were able to choose some new computer programs for my students to use in the classroom, Shelly, Gunter, & Gunter (2010) have some great tips on evaluating educational technology. “To evaluate an item is to determine its value or judge its worth” (p. 392). Through evaluating educational technology, you are essentially looking for technology that is appropriate for a specific grade level and promotes “learning at the correct levels of student ability and academic achievement” (p. 392). When searching for new educational technologies to use in your classroom, there are many places you can go for assistance. School districts and departments of education have software evaluations to view. Some other places you can go to for help include: professional educational organizations, browsing technology catalogs, colleague recommendations, published evaluations of new products, technology conferences, or the web. There are many software evaluations out there to help educators decide when purchasing new educational technologies for the classroom. You just have to use all of your resources and spend some time searching for the right program. New educational programs can be expensive so you want to research as much as possible before purchasing, so that you know you made the right investment in your students’ education. Education World has a great website with educator product evaluations. Since the products are evaluated by educators, I value other educator’s opinions and know they are keeping their student’s interests in mind when evaluating educational technology.
When evaluating software applications, Shelly, Gunter, & Gunter (2010) recommend downloading a free trial from the software company to test out the software. That is a great, inexpensive way to test out potential software for your classroom. At no cost you can evaluate whether the software meets your student’s needs. You can also use a software evaluation rubric to assess a software program. It “provides a number of important evaluation criteria…to help assess the quality of software or other items” (p. 396). Here is an example that I found of a very user-friendly software evaluation rubric for teachers.
Some other factors Shelly, Gunter, & Gunter (2010) recommend you consider when evaluating educational software are: the content, technical support, ability levels, assessment, technical quality, and ease of use. When taking all of these factors into consideration, you will have a better understanding of the program you are evaluating and it will help you decide if it is a program worth purchasing.
The web also provides access to hundreds of thousands of programs and websites to support your students’ learning. Just like with software, websites should also be evaluated before allowing your students to use them. Some things to look for when evaluating websites are: authority (the credibility of the author), affiliation (to schools or organizations), purpose (why was the site created?), objectivity (is it free from bias?), content, learning process, intended audience, currency (is the information up to date?), and the design of the website (Shelly, Gunter, & Gunter, 2010). You can use a web evaluation rubric to assess the value of an educational website. Take a look at this sample rubric for evaluating websites. There are even rubrics for your students to evaluate websites as well!
As a test, I used the web evaluation rubric to assess one of the websites that I used on my curriculum page. How well did I do with that task? I must say, having a rubric as a guide to assessing the website made it a lot easier to decide if the website is appropriate for my students. I wish I would have known about web evaluation rubrics before creating my curriculum page so I would have put more consideration into the sites that I chose. Since I have a few weeks before my curriculum page is officially due, I think I will go back and evaluate each website using the website evaluation rubric to make sure it is a good choice for my students to view as part of their project assignment. I now realize how important evaluating educational technology really is. I am responsible for my students’ safety and education, and when they come into the classroom I need to protect each student and guide him or her toward positive educational experiences.
With kind regards,
Kim
References:
Shelly, G., Gunter, G., & Gunter, R. (2010). Integrating Technology and Classroom Media in the Classroom. Boston: Course Technology.